Detection of suspicious blue objects in the Taurus Molecular
Cloud
with the 2nd incremental data release
a. Identification of suspicious objects:
-
Color-color and color-magnitude diagrams (Figure
1)
The examination of photometry in a 4 square degrees field in the Taurus
molecular cloud leads to the identification of about 50 objects with H-Ks<-0.5
and J-Ks<0. The color of these objects cannot be explained
by the presence of the cloud itself: extinction reddens stars and young
stellar objects associated with a cloud never have any blue excess. The
color-color diagram indicates that the problem is with the Ks
photometry.
The blue stars have uniform spatial distribution in the 4 square
degrees field and their Ks magnitude range from 11 to 18. Because
of the uniform distribution of the blue stars, and because they
are mixed in with stars having normal colors, the erroneous Ks
photometry is not caused by the photometric normalization error described
in the Gizis's
page.
 |
| Figure 1 |
b. Understand what occurs:
-
Comparison with the aperture photometry
Figure
2 compares the aperture photometry with the photometry obtained by
PSF fitting for J, H and Ks. The Ks photometry can
be incriminated: PSF fitted photometry in Ks appears to be from
1 to 3 magnitudes fainter than aperture photometry for the blue
stars. Blue diamonds in Figure
3 represent the PSF fitted photometry of the blue stars and
green diamonds represent same stars with the aperture photometry. The locus
of selected stars seems correct with aperture photometry (stars are spread
along the main sequence line).
 |
 |
| Figure 2 |
Figure 3 |
-
Information about the PSF fitting in the catalogue
The Point Source Catalogue contains the Ks band reduced
chi-squared value of fit. Figure
4 shows this value for all stars in the field (black) and for blue
stars (red diamonds). Virtually all of the sources with bad Ks
magnitudes have large chi-squared value. However, other sources with large
chi-squared value show usual color.
Figure
5 presents J, H and Ks chi-squared value on the same graph:
most of stars have good value in J and H.
 |
 |
| Figure 4 |
Figure 5 |
Objects incriminated in this analysis have a close companion or an
extension which contaminates the stellar flux (Figure
6).
For this field, a companion is detected in 80% of the case at a distance
lower than 6 arcsecs and it has always the same chi-squared value
of fit in Ks than the brightest star. Companions are also detected
in J and H, but the photometry in those bands is not affected.
 |
| Figure 6 |
The problem has been identified: the anomalous Ks magnitudes
are due to the inadequate design of the passive deblending algorithm currently
used in 2MASS photometric processing (PROPHOT). Sources are photometered
in decreasing order of brightness, and sources that fall within a certain
critical radius of a given source are reduced
together as a group. This would have been okay, except that the neighboring
sources were never revisited during subsequent reduction, which meant that
no account was taken of the possibility that the outlying neighbors
might have been contaminated by other sources outside the original
radius.
The passive-deblending deficiency has been rectified in a new version
of PROPHOT that will be delivered with the new production PSFs. As an illustration
of the new process, scan 063 from 971129 was reprocessed using the revised
PROPHOT, and the results are presented in
Figure
7. The chi squared values for the formerly-blue stars are now
different. The values are still high because of the contamination by the
close companion but the systematic shift in photometry toward blue color
is no longer present.
 |
| Figure 7 |
Laurent Cambrésy
March 2000