Comet Encke

Background: Dust trails
Comets produce a lot of dust, and that dust is responsible for bright infrared emission. The predominant picture of comets is a `dirty snowball', which is based on the fact that they emit a lot of gas when they get close enough to the Sun to make water ice sublimate. In fact, this view needs to be modified, based on the results of infrared astronomy, which was nearly nonexistent at the time of the `dirty snowball'. The Infrared Astronomical Satellite in 1983 gave us our first complete survey of the infrared sky, unhindered by the smothering effect of the Earth's atmosphere on ground-based observations. A landmark discovery was that of cometary dust trails, which are large particles that fill the orbits of short-period comets. To account for all of the particles that are in the dust trails, the comet must actually emit more mass in solid particles than in gas. Considering that the solid particles are even harder to get off of the comet than gas molecules, the comet must actually be composed of a solid rocky material, not just ice with a few dust particles. Therefore, Mark Syskes, who discovered the dust trails, has proposed that the comet model be renamed a `frozen mudball'.
A trail is actually the same thing as a meteor shower, but seen in a different way. When the Earth passes through one of these "trails" we see a lot of large meteors entering the atmosphere. That is a meteor shower. If the Earth doesn't go through a particular comet's orbit, then we won't have any extra meteors. But it was found in 1983 that we can see the meteor streams of comets as long, nearly straight streaks of infrared emission centered on periodic comets. This discovery was made with the Infrared Astronomical Satellite: the first telescope that systematically observed the sky in the mid-infrared waveband.

Comet Encke observed by ISO: a closer look at a frozen mudball in action

Below is a schematic view of the dust trail, comparing it to the other well-known parts of a comet--the nucleus, coma, and tail. The trail makes a straight line across the image. It contains substantially more mass than the tail and coma, even though it is not as bright, because the trail is composed of large particles that have relatively less surface area. Just as optical observations are biased toward the emission from gas, the infrared surface brightness observations are biased toward the smaller dust particles that have more surface area per unit mass. The sensitive observations possible from space revealed the dust trail, which continues well out of the picture shown here,  stretching over at least 60 degrees of the comet's orbit!

We took a  picture of comet 2P/Encke using the Infrared Space Observatory (ISO) this July (14th). The image was made by pointing the telescope in a regular grid of positions and taking a picture at each position using the mid-infrared camera (ISOCAM). The comet was moving pretty fast--it moved about half-way across the area that we mapped, during our observation! So to put all the iamges together, I shifted each individual image by exactly opposite the motion of the comet. The picture above is actually a black and white, smoother version of the ISO image--it is not an artist's rendition! Look at the real picture by clicking the link here. In the real picture, the stars appear as multiple "dots" because the telescope moved with respect to them, but the comet appears in a single frame. The goal of these observations was to observe the large particles that are ejected by the comet. The "tail" of a comet is well-known from the appearance of the comet in visible light: it is due to very small dust particles and also emission from ices and vapors emitted by the comet. The "trail" of a comet is a different phenomenon: large particles (rocks and boulders) that fall off of a comet have orbits not too different from the comet itself. They are blown off of the comet relatively gently and then they slowly drift away. (The small particles move more quickly away from the comet because they are dragged by the fast-moving gas and because they feel radiation pressure from sunlight.) These large particles for what we call a "trail" that fills the orbit of the parent comet.

The observations shown below are an attempt to see at higher resolution how the trail connects to the parent comet. We already know that the trail contains much more material than the tail, and that the "rocks" that comprise the trail are numerous enough that the comet cannot survive too long before losing a good fraction of its total mass. More details will be forthcoming. This project is a collaboration between myself (William Reach) and Mark Sykes of U. Arizona, John Davies of the Joint Astronomy Center in Hawaii, and David Lien of Vanguard Research in Scotts Valley California.

color image

Back to research highlights...

Back to my home page...